...
...
Next Story

Information on judges’ elevation not apt for RTI act, A-G tells SC

A five-judge Supreme Court bench is hearing an appeal by the top court’s registry against a 2010 Delhi high court judgment that held that the Chief Justice of India’s (CJI) office is a “public authority”.

Updated on: Apr 3, 2019, 23:39:29 IST
New Delhi |
Advertisement

Information on the elevation and non-elevation of judges should not be made public under the Right to Information (RTI) Act as it would “open a Pandora’s box” and do “great damage to the judiciary”, attorney general KK Venugopal told the Supreme Court on Wednesday. He, however, favoured disclosure of information about the assets of judges.

A view of the Supreme Court in New Delhi. (HT File Photo)
A view of the Supreme Court in New Delhi. (HT File Photo)

A five-judge Supreme Court bench is hearing an appeal by the top court’s registry against a 2010 Delhi high court judgment that held that the Chief Justice of India’s (CJI) office is a “public authority”. The high court said the office falls under the ambit of the RTI Act, which allows Indian citizens to seek information from the government on grounds of accountability and transparency. The high court also directed the registry to give information to an RTI activist on the assets of judges. The Collegium’s (system of selecting judges) decision on January 10 recommending justice Sanjiv Khanna’s elevation to the top court triggered a controversy as his appointment entailed supersession of three Delhi high court judges.

Venugopal told the court that the moment the bar knows that a particular judge is to be elevated, 50 to 60 complaints are filed. “Even rival judges ask people to file complaints.

Venugopal said the principle of larger public interest must be followed with regard to the disclosure of assets of judges.

“As far as the information on assets is concerned, it is personal and private. One has to see if larger public interest is served, then the information can be disclosed.” He cited examples of civil servants and Parliament members to drive his point home.

“These people are public servants, and by the very nature of the functions they perform, there is a possibility that they can misuse their powers and acquire huge wealth…”

On a lighter note, Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi said, “There are judges, who started very rich, but are poor now. How many people are interested in knowing this?”

The court asked Venugopal whether the information on assets of members of Parliament is put in the public domain or it was just given to the Speaker of the House.

 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Follow the latest breaking news, major developments and agenda-setting stories from India and around the world with the newsdesk at Hindustan Times. Operating round the clock, the desk brings together experienced editors, reporters and correspondents to deliver fast, accurate and contextual reporting across subjects that influence public policy, governance, business, society and international affairs. The HT News Desk covers politics, elections, government policies, the economy, business and markets, science and technology, the environment, law and order, infrastructure, education, climate issues and geopolitics, while closely tracking developments across states, institutions and global capitals. The team also leads coverage of major breaking news events, policy announcements, court proceedings, natural disasters, public emergencies and significant international developments. Reports published by the newsdesk are based on information gathered from reporters on the ground, official statements, government agencies, court records, regulatory filings, recognised institutions and other authoritative sources. Stories undergo editorial scrutiny and verification processes to ensure accuracy, fairness and relevance, and are updated as events evolve and additional information becomes available. Whether covering a key political decision in New Delhi, an economic policy shift affecting millions, a landmark court ruling or a major global event, the HT News Desk aims to provide readers with reliable, fact-based journalism that delivers not only the latest developments but also the context and analysis needed to understand their wider implications.

Get Latest News, breaking headlines, and top India News, and today real-time updates from across the nation. Stay informed on politics, government policies, crime, Today Weather, and major developments on Hindustan Times
Get Latest News, breaking headlines, and top India News, and today real-time updates from across the nation. Stay informed on politics, government policies, crime, Today Weather, and major developments on Hindustan Times
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Notifications

Get breaking alerts directly from the newsroom

Notifications are on!You'll be notified when news breaks