India should only worry about decarbonisation when it gets richer: Steven Koonin at HT Leadership Summit
The physicist says United Nations climate talks have failed to curb emissions or deliver promised finance.
India should get the energy it needs in the most convenient way that it can and must only worry about decarbonisation when “it gets rich enough”, physicist Steven Koonin said at the Hindustan Times Leadership Summit on Saturday.

“The energy needs [of the developing world] are immediate, whereas the climate threat is distant, vague and uncertain,” said Koonin, the Edward Teller Fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution.
India’s first priority should be development, which would make it more resilient, Koonin said. The second priority, for all countries, should be technologies that cut emissions without costing more than coal or natural gas.
Cutting emissions too quickly was “very disruptive and very expensive”, he said, citing Germany, which shut down its nuclear reactors and gave up coal in favour of imported gas.
In a 35-minute conversation with NDTV consulting editor Gargi Rawat, Koonin said the world was moving towards decarbonisation – the process of slashing the levels of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases in the atmosphere – even as developing countries like India needed “more and more energy” to meet their growth targets.
Also Read | Germany poster child of suffering in pursuit decarbonisation: scientist Steven Koonin | HTLS 2026
The 74-year-old, whose work straddles energy, climate science and science policy, served as undersecretary for science in the US energy department under president Barack Obama. In 2025, he was a member of the department’s Climate Working Group and coauthored the report “A Critical Review of Impacts of Greenhouse Gas Emissions on the U.S. Climate”, which argues that the effects of these emissions on the environment are vastly exaggerated.
For three decades, the global energy debate has focussed on decarbonisation and forgotten “two other important, essential qualities of energy”, Koonin said. “One is that it be reliable, and that it be affordable. For too long we have given too much emphasis to that decarbonisation, in the frankly misguided perception that there’s a climate catastrophe ahead of us.”
In a presentation before the discussion, Koonin outlined data that he said showed that India “warmed modestly over 125 years”. The country has warmed about 0.68 degrees over the last century, about 2.5 times less than the rest of the land average, he said. “You can see perhaps some acceleration in the warming over the last 20 or 30 years,” he added.
Koonin also criticised multilateral platforms designed to rein in the impacts of climate change, including the Conference of the Parties, the 31st edition of which is under way in Turkey.
“What have they accomplished? Global emissions continue to go up. They are soaring. The promises of financial help from the developed world to the developing world have not materialised. I think it’s time to think about doing the response in a different way than what we have done,” he said.
Also Read | Stanford's Steven Koonin on why he doesn't believe humanity is facing climate disaster| HTLS 2026
“In the last five years, let’s say, there has been, in my opinion, a refreshing trend toward climate realism. So you see organisations and people who were formerly alarmist – ‘Oh, got to decarbonise, net zero by 2050’ and so on – realising just how hard that is, and also perhaps that we don’t need to do it so rapidly,” he said, citing the work of Bill Gates and the policies of Canadian prime minister Mark Carney as examples.
Asked about the 2026 flash floods in Nepal that killed nearly 1,500, Koonin said: “So the human activities – where do people live? Do they have a warning system, which they did not have in Nepal? Those contribute as much, if not more, than anything associated with changing climate.”
On whether a poor country such as Nepal had grounds to seek climate compensation, Koonin declined to answer. “You know, I’m just a lowly physicist ... That’s a very complicated moral and diplomatic issue. So I’m going to pass on that,” he said.
Rawat said Koonin’s arguments risked giving western nations an excuse to do less to combat climate change and to help developing countries.
Koonin said the US and Europe were “in big trouble” financially. “To think that there’s going to be massive amounts of aid coming from the West, given the financial problems that we have ... I don’t think that’s going to happen,” he said.
On geoengineering – putting aerosols into the upper atmosphere to reduce the sunlight the planet absorbs – Koonin said it was technically and economically feasible but carried “a lot of downsides”.
“It might reduce the sunlight and hence cool the planet, but it will change the precipitation patterns in ways that we don’t understand,” he said, adding that it should be used only in extreme circumstances.
Also Read | 'Climate Crisis' sceptic Koonin on why disaster-hit nations shouldn't expect western aid| HTLS 2026
In response to a question on artificial intelligence, Koonin cited a 1972 paper by Anthony Downs on the “issue-attention cycle”, under which public concern over an ecological issue surges, fades once people realise how hard and expensive the solutions are, and is then displaced by another issue.
“We are now seeing AI displacing climate change,” he said.
Pressed by Rawat on the scientific evidence and consensus that human activities were driving the climate crisis, Koonin said: “I would not at all deny that humans are having some impact on the climate. Of course we are. That follows from basic physical principles. The question is: how does the climate respond to human influences beyond getting warmer? We’re going to see more storms? We’re going to see sea level rising more rapidly, etc.? And again, from the data, we’re not seeing that.”

E-Paper

