...
...
Next Story

‘Dialling wrong number’: CJI Surya Kant-led Supreme Court bench on plea seeking rotation of SC/ST seats

The top court said mandatory rotation of SC/ST reserved constituencies was for Parliament to decide, telling the petitioner he was “dialling the wrong number”.

Updated on: Nov 4, 2026, 18:02:12 IST
Advertisement

The Supreme Court on Wednesday told the petitioner that the demand for mandatory rotation of seats reserved for Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs) in Parliament and state assemblies was a matter for the legislature, not the judiciary.

A view of the Supreme Court of India, in New Delhi, Aug. 13, 2026. (PTI)
A view of the Supreme Court of India, in New Delhi, Aug. 13, 2026. (PTI)

A bench, comprising Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant and justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, remarked that he was “dialling the wrong number” and suggested that he approach elected representatives to build consensus for a change in the law.

Declining to interfere with an Allahabad High Court judgment, the bench upheld the validity of Section 9 (1)(c) of the Delimitation Act, 2002, which requires reserved constituencies to be identified in areas where the proportion of SC/ST residents is comparatively large. The provision does not mandate periodic rotation of such constituencies.

Also Read | Supreme Court to hear plea on EC's Form 6 clarification amid concerns over Delhi voter roll revision

It reiterated that the petitioner could approach elected representatives and seek a consensus for introducing the rotation principle through legislation.

The petition was filed by Jagdish Singh, an elector of the 191-Kadipur assembly constituency in Uttar Pradesh’s Sultanpur district, which has remained reserved for SC candidates for nearly seven decades. The plea argued that the absence of rotation violated the right to equality and other fundamental rights, including Articles 14, 15 and 19 of the Constitution, and restricted voters to choosing candidates only from the SC community. He also contended that the arrangement benefited a handful of families rather than the larger community and sought a rotation mechanism similar to the one provided for panchayats and municipalities under Articles 243D and 243T.

Also Read | Assembly’s remaining tenure no ground to delay anti-defection pleas, rules Supreme Court

During the hearing, the court questioned the premise of the petitioner’s argument that concentrating reserved constituencies in areas with a larger SC/ST population entrenched caste divisions.

It observed that in a multiparty democracy, voters were expected to choose representatives on the basis of political ideology rather than caste or religion. “In a political democracy, there are multiple political parties having different ideologies. The voters are usually expected to cast their vote for the party, not for the caste or religion. You may like or dislike a particular political ideology. Who is representing that ideology becomes irrelevant. You vote for that ideology. So that also defeats your argument,” it said.

The court also distinguished between the right to vote and any claimed right to contest elections from a particular constituency, pointing out that candidates from the general category remained free to contest from unreserved seats.

When the petitioner pressed for judicial intervention, it remarked: “You are dialling the wrong number.” The bench suggested that the demand should instead be taken to Parliament, adding in a lighter vein:

“This is a good season of protests, naarebaazi (sloganeering). So, this is also a good ground for protest.”

The petitioner pointed out that the high court had itself acknowledged that rotation would be an ideal arrangement but had declined to issue directions, citing judicial restraint.

But the bench questioned the assumption that voters in constituencies with a larger SC population would necessarily vote along caste lines and that reservation in such seats was therefore unnecessary. “That proceeds on the idea that a majority community will vote on community or caste lines. They may not vote on community and caste lines. The high court cannot judicially pronounce on a democratic choice. That is for the voters to decide,” it added.

Also Read | Supreme Court to hear plea on EC's Form 6 clarification amid concerns over Delhi voter roll revision

The court made it clear that it could not introduce a rotation requirement into the constitutional and statutory framework when neither Articles 330 and 332, which provide for reservation of seats for SCs and STs in the Lok Sabha and state legislative assemblies, nor the Delimitation Act prescribed such a mechanism.

In its order, the court said the high court had rightly declined to direct the introduction of rotation, holding that the matter fell within Parliament’s domain. “We see no ground to take a different view,” said the bench, while allowing the petitioner to approach public representatives to build consensus around the rotation principle, which he relied upon with reference to the reservation exercise undertaken by the delimitation commission in 2008.

 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Utkarsh Anand is the National Legal Editor at Hindustan Times, where he leads the newspaper's coverage of the Supreme Court, constitutional law, the judiciary and the Union law ministry. He joined Hindustan Times in 2020 after stints at Press Trust of India (PTI), The Indian Express and CNN-News18, and has over two decades of experience reporting on law, governance and public policy. His work has focussed on some of India's most consequential constitutional and legal developments, including the Supreme Court's judgments on Article 370, marriage equality, decriminalisation of homosexuality, the Babri Masjid dispute, electoral reforms and judicial appointments. He specialises in making complex legal proceedings and judgments accessible to readers while examining their wider social and political impact. Beyond daily reportage, Utkarsh has led investigative projects and enterprise reporting that have shaped public debate and prompted institutional responses. His work has received several journalism awards, including the Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Award. As National Legal Editor, he has also played a key role in expanding Hindustan Times' legal journalism footprint, mentoring reporters and strengthening coverage across platforms. A Chevening South Asia Journalism Programme Fellow, Utkarsh regularly writes analyses on the judiciary and constitutional issues, and his reporting is widely followed by lawyers, judges, policymakers, academics and readers seeking clarity on India's evolving legal landscape.

Get Latest News, breaking headlines, and top India News, and today real-time updates from across the nation. Stay informed on politics, government policies, crime, Today Weather, and major developments on Hindustan Times
Get Latest News, breaking headlines, and top India News, and today real-time updates from across the nation. Stay informed on politics, government policies, crime, Today Weather, and major developments on Hindustan Times
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Notifications

Get breaking alerts directly from the newsroom

Notifications are on!You'll be notified when news breaks