Sign in

‘Without Rafale, how can we resist F-16s’: Centre to Supreme Court

The Centre has told the Supreme Court that defence procurements done by the government can’t be examined by judiciary.

Updated on: Mar 6, 2019, 17:24:59 IST
Hindustan Times, New Delhi | By
Share
Share via
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
Copy link
  • copy link

The Centre on Wednesday urged the Supreme Court to “exercise restraint” in observations on the procurement of Rafale fighter jets, underlining that every statement by the Supreme Court will be used to target either the government or the opposition.

The Narendra Modi government signed an agreement with France in 2016 for the purchase of Rafale fighter jets. (PTI)
The Narendra Modi government signed an agreement with France in 2016 for the purchase of Rafale fighter jets. (PTI)

“Why should the court become a party to such an exercise,” the government’s top lawyer KK Venugopal told the bench that is to decide pleas to review its December ruling that did not find anything amiss in the deal.

Venugopal’s cautionary note to the judges comes at a time the Rafale deal is at the heart of the opposition campaign against government ahead of the Lok Sabha elections. The Congress-led opposition alleges malfeasance in the purchase to buy 36 fighter jets in an overpriced deal, a charge that the government denies.

The Narendra Modi government signed an agreement with France in 2016 for the purchase of Rafale fighter jets. Under the Rs 59,000-crore deal, French firm, Dassault Aviation will supply 36 Rafale fighter jets to India in flyaway condition. The delivery will begin from September this year.

“Every statement by this Court will be used to destablise either the government or the opposition….This is why I am appealing to this Court to exercise restraint. Defence procurements can’t be judicially examined,” Attorney General Venugopal told a bench headed by Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi.

Venugopal also referred to the recent intrusion by F-16 fighter jets of Pakistan Air Force in retaliation to Indian Air Force’s strikes at a Jaish terror camp run in Pakistan to justify the Rafale purchase.

“We are trying to protect the security of the country… Some F-16s come and bomb us. What we are to do?” he said.

“Without the Rafale, how can we resist them,” the attorney general told the top court, according to news agency PTI. He stressed that though the MiG-21 Bison of the 1960s “performed beautifully against F-16, the Rafale jets were still needed.

Venugopal told the court that “two squadrons of Rafale fighter jets are coming in flyaway condition, first one will be in September this year.”

He contended that if a probe by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) is ordered now, “huge damage will be done to the country”.

During pre-lunch hearing on petitions, Venugopal told the court that the documents relied upon by Bhushan were stolen from the defence ministry. He argued that the documents can’t be admitted for considering the review petition by the Supreme Court.

The “stolen document” saw heated exchange between Justice KM Joseph and AG Venugopal, Justice Joseph appeared to dismiss the government’s argument to reject the notes cited by Bhushan. “There were allegations of corruption in Bofors. Will you say the same thing that a criminal court shouldn’t look into any such document,” Justice Joseph asked Venugopal.

Bhushan countered the government’s argument saying that in previous cases including the one relating to coal scam, he had submitted the documents given to him by whistleblowers. The Supreme Court did not ask for the source then.

CJI Googi told Bhushan, “If we accept the attorney general’s arguments, we will not look into the documents relied on by you and we will reject it. Or, we will look into the papers and see how they are relevant and decide the case.”

The apex court adjourned the hearing in the case till March 14.

  • HT News Desk
    ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    HT News Desk

    Follow the latest breaking news, major developments and agenda-setting stories from India and around the world with the newsdesk at Hindustan Times. Operating round the clock, the desk brings together experienced editors, reporters and correspondents to deliver fast, accurate and contextual reporting across subjects that influence public policy, governance, business, society and international affairs. The HT News Desk covers politics, elections, government policies, the economy, business and markets, science and technology, the environment, law and order, infrastructure, education, climate issues and geopolitics, while closely tracking developments across states, institutions and global capitals. The team also leads coverage of major breaking news events, policy announcements, court proceedings, natural disasters, public emergencies and significant international developments. Reports published by the newsdesk are based on information gathered from reporters on the ground, official statements, government agencies, court records, regulatory filings, recognised institutions and other authoritative sources. Stories undergo editorial scrutiny and verification processes to ensure accuracy, fairness and relevance, and are updated as events evolve and additional information becomes available. Whether covering a key political decision in New Delhi, an economic policy shift affecting millions, a landmark court ruling or a major global event, the HT News Desk aims to provide readers with reliable, fact-based journalism that delivers not only the latest developments but also the context and analysis needed to understand their wider implications.Read More